About

Island Insurance has been providing exceptional insurance services to the Key West community for over 45 years. Founded by Tim Tomita who, at just 18 years old, began his career in the formal insurance agency called Mr. Auto. After the previous owners relocated, Tim stepped in to purchase and rename the business to Island Insurance. Under his leadership, the business has grown tremendously, thanks in no small part to the tireless efforts of his office manager, Ayden, who has been by his side for decades.

Find us

Tim and his team offer a wide range of insurance options, including auto, business, homeowners, windstorm, flood, boats, and more, all with competitive rates. As a dedicated member of the Key West community, Tim has always been committed to providing high-quality service to his neighbors. When he's not in the office, Tim enjoys spending time with his family on their small island, where close community ties are cherished. At Island Insurance, fast and reliable customer service is always a top priority.